Historical cookbook
The Good Housekeeper: Sarah Hale's Guide to Victorian Home Cooking
Sarah Josepha Hale's 1841 American household manual, and the source of our modernised Election Cake.
The story behind the book
The Good Housekeeper was an American household manual of the early Victorian era, written when printed advice was starting to supplement handed-down family know-how in many middle-class homes. Recipe Filer works from the 1841 edition, although some library records list an earlier Boston printing in 1839, so the exact first-edition date is worth checking if you intend to cite it. The full title promised a way to live well and to be well while we live, which shows the book's aim: sensible, thrifty and healthy housekeeping rather than display. It belongs to the same generation of American domestic guides as the work of Lydia Maria Child and Eliza Leslie, and it was written for cooks in American kitchens rather than for readers following British or French habits.
Who wrote it
Sarah Josepha Hale (1788 to 1879) was born in Newport, New Hampshire. She was widowed in 1822 with five young children and turned to writing to support them. Her novel Northwood appeared in 1827, and she went on to edit the Ladies' Magazine in Boston. From 1837 she edited Godey's Lady's Book, based in Philadelphia, and she held that post for around four decades, making her one of the most influential magazine editors of her century. The nursery poem Mary Had a Little Lamb, published in 1830, is credited to her. She is also remembered for her long campaign for a national Thanksgiving holiday, which President Lincoln proclaimed in 1863. A cookery book from such a writer carries the voice of a professional editor: plain, orderly and keen to instruct.
What's inside
The Good Housekeeper is a general household guide, pairing recipes with advice on running a home and keeping a family in good health. Its cookery covers the everyday repertoire of the period, including puddings, cakes, breads and preserves, written in the compact style of the time, with few exact quantities and little guidance on oven temperature. That is why modernising it takes care. Recipe Filer's version of Sarah Josepha Hale's Election Cake follows this tradition. Election cake is a spiced, yeast-raised fruit cake linked to New England and to the days when elections and militia musters brought crowds together, and old versions were often made in very large batches. Our version brings the quantities down to suit a home kitchen, uses metric and imperial measures, gives oven temperatures, and keeps the character of the original: a lightly enriched, fruited dough that needs time to rise.
Why it still matters
Books like this show how American home cooking was written down and shared before standardised measuring and reliable ovens. Reading Hale alongside her contemporaries shows how a recipe moved from memory to print, and how a magazine editor's authority helped shape what a respectable table looked like. For British cooks the interest is practical as well as historical. Election cake sits somewhere between a bun loaf, a tea bread and a fruit cake, so the method will feel familiar to anyone who bakes with yeast. Working from Hale's text, with careful adjustments, lets you taste an early nineteenth-century American recipe without guessing at what the original cook meant.
Recipes from The Good Housekeeper
Frequently asked questions
Who wrote The Good Housekeeper?
+
It was written by Sarah Josepha Hale, the American author and long-serving editor of Godey's Lady's Book, who is also credited with the poem Mary Had a Little Lamb.
When was The Good Housekeeper first published?
+
Recipe Filer dates the book to 1841, though some library records list an earlier Boston printing in 1839, so check the edition you are citing.
What is election cake?
+
Election cake is a spiced, yeast-raised fruit cake associated with New England and election-day gatherings. Recipe Filer has modernised Hale's version for a home kitchen.













